Tuesday, January 7, 2014

Repairing intermittent wifi/wireless on a 15" Macbook Pro 2011

From reading a couple of articles on this site, you may have noticed that although I may be critical of some Apple goods, in general, I am a fan. However, there are some times that I am extremely fustrated when their hardware breaks, such as when my MacBook Pro 15" wifi decided to start acting abnormally. For reference, it have a Macbook Pro 15" Unibody Early 2011 (Released February 2011 2.2 GHz Quad-core Intel Core i7 Processor, thunderbolt, Broadcom BCM94331PCIEBT4AX wifi/bluetooth card)




The issue
After a while of use, the wireless internet dies. The signal strength indicator fan in the top right corner still indicates five full bars. Right Clicking on the icon and clicking on "Turn wi-fi off" makes the fan icon go blank as it should, but the previously connected to network remains in the list check marked, which it shouldnt. All other wifi networks in the area disappear from the list. The status at the top of the drop down box says "Wi-Fi: looking for networks".
Right clicking on the icon and clicking on "Turn wifi-off" makes the icon go blank, as it should. Right-clicking on the icon and clicking on "Turn Wifi-On" does not enable the wifi. The fan icon stays blank, which it shouldn't. The previously "connected to" network remains check marked, but there is no connection to the internet.
Putting the laptop to sleep with the lid and waking it again results in five faded bars, but now no wifi networks can be found, and there is no connection to the internet. The issue occurred round once a day at the beginning. By saving my work and rebooting the laptop, the issue has been manageable. However, it became unmanageable when it occurred more and more often to the point where I had to save my work reboot my laptop every 1-2 hours of use.

What I tried to do to repair the issue

  1. Reboot the laptop. A temporary solution is to reboot the laptop, in which the wifi performs as it should until the issue occurs again.
  2. Use a USB dongle. A semi permanent solution was for me to buy a Ralink usb wifi adapter, that worked fine but was not ideal. It felt a bit ridiculous and cumbersome to have to use a $10 usb adapter to repair a Macbook Pro that cost $2000.
  3. Connect to a different wifi network. This did not work. The issue occurs when connected to other wifi networks, such as my parents one at home. This hinted that it was not a wireless router issue.
  4. Reset PRAM, NRAM, etc. This was only a temporary solution, as was just simply rebooting the laptop.
  5. Deleting my Airport settings files. Again, this was only a temporary solution, bus so was simply rebooting.
  6. Wiped the harddrive and installed Mountain Lion. The issue remained, even with a clean installation with no restoration of my old settings from TimeMachine. The issue was the same when I installed Lion, and Mavericks. I even noticed the same issue once with the wifi when I booted off just the OSX installation disk. As such, I believed that the the issue is hardware related.
  7. Visual inspection of the hardware. I took off the bottom cover of the laptop to see if there are any visually obvious loose connections, but there are none.
  8. Took the laptop to an authorised Apple Repair Center. They did nothing. As it was an intermittent issue, they said that the wifi was working fine when they ran their DVD of hardware tests. As far as I know, they don't do any long-term tests, even though I had requested them to do so. They blamed the wireless router (which I knew was not an issue, see above) and mu wifi settings (which I also knew was not an issue, see above).
  9. Replaced the wifi card. This did not work. I bought a new Broadcom BCM94331PCIEBT4AX for around $35 off eBay. Following a guide on ifixit, http://www.ifixit.com/Guide/MacBook+Pro+15-Inch+Unibody+Early+2011+AirPort-Bluet ooth+Cable+Replacement/5887 I replaced the card easily enough. It was just around 10 screws in total, easily manageable in an hour if you take your time. Unfortunately, the issue returned again after a few hours of use. 
  10. Replaced the motherboard, and the screen. I assume means that the wifi antennas got replaced. This did not work. On an unrelated issue with the graphics card, Apple agreed to replace the motherboard, LVDS, and LCD screen out of warranty (really good of them). Unfortunately, their authorised repair center took nearly 6 months to do the repair (again, they were a bad representation of Apple). Unfortunately, the wifi issue returned once again after a few hours of work.


What repaired it in the end
Finally, in a last ditch attempt, and as it seemed to be the only part in the laptop not replaced (including software), I bought a replacement wifi/bluetooth cable off ebay for around $30. This worked! It has been going strong now for nearly three weeks with no drop in wifi. It was pretty expensive for a simple black ribbon cable but I am glad that it worked. There was no visual damage to the old cable, but I suspect myself that the bottom cover may have pinched the cable against some edge near the motherboard, thus causing the intermittent drop-off in wifi.

Update 20/01/2013 : I have re-opened the laptop to inspect the location of the ribbon cable (Figure 1). In (Figure 2) you can see the point on the rear of bottom cover (2) that places pressure on the end of the ribbon cable. You can see that there is a visible imprint on the plastic foil covering the back of where they are in contact. Due to the level of imprint and its location, I suspect that this causes excess pressure on the cable connector when the laptop receives knocks from the underside.

Figure 1: The faulty macbook wifi cable is shown in (1). The point on the back cover that I suspect may have been putting too much pressure on the ribbon cable is located at (2)

Figure 2: The point on the rear of bottom cover (2) that places pressure on the end of the ribbon cable. You can see that there is a visible imprint on the plastic foil covering the back of where they are in contact. Due to the level of imprint and its location, I suspect that this causes excess pressure on the cable connector when the laptop receives knocks from the underside. 




12 comments:

  1. Do you have a serial number or something for the cable? I found one online, but that's for the 13 inch - which might be different? And is it complicated to install, or can anyone do it? I'd love to get rid of the stupid USB dongle sticking out of my 3,000 euro Macbook Pro!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Hi Jerry, The serial number for my 15" 2011 macbook pro was 821-1311-02. If yours is a 13", it may be different.

      Delete
  2. We had the same problem at the office with one MacBook 15". WiFi would work after boot, but no longer when the Mac woke up from sleep. Eventually it lost the WiFi card altogether ("WiFi: no hardware installed" when clicking the menubar symbol). We tried to replace the WiFi card, but that obviously didn't help, as the cable was faulty.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Hey, I had a great time reading your website. Would you please consider adding a link to my website on your page. Please email me back.

    Regards,

    Joel
    JHouston791 gmail.com

    ReplyDelete
  4. Hi,

    I wanted to thank you for this article. I had similar problems on a MacBook Pro 13" Early 2011, where it started with WiFi switched off after sleep. They replaced the WiFi card on warranty, but the issue returned.

    Finally, I opted to order myself a cable to replace it, which worked flawlessly. So thank you for the hint. (Now on some networks I'm just stuck with full WiFi connection, but the alert that no internet connection is available. Despite the fact that it actually works.)

    @Jerry: my original (broken) cable had a serial 821-1312-A (MacBook Pro 13" Early 2011,)

    Cheers, Fabian

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Great news! I am glad that the solution worked for you as I could not find a similar one online.

      Delete
  5. Man, I'm having this same problem with my MacBook Pro (late 2012, bought it brand new, two months ago). I've tried several different approaches, nothing works as a long term fix. I'm also seeing lots of people facing this issue too with many different models -- Air, Pro, Retina, etc. I'm still not sure why replacing the cable could fix the problem, but I will surely look for one in Brazil. :)

    ReplyDelete
  6. Thank you - been having exact same problems on my 2011 MacBook Pro 15" and been searching for solutions - just ordered a new cable - your efforts are greatly appreciated

    ReplyDelete
  7. I had the same problems... searching for the solution, I found your website.
    I just wanna say... thank you!! I bought a second hand flex (a bit longer that the original one, no silver plate on the top, I guess that it is from a different model) and now, my macbook pro i7 late 2011 works flawlessly!!

    ReplyDelete
  8. I had the same problem on 2011 Macbook Pro 15". New flex cable installed. Works like a charm.

    Brilliant! Thanks.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great facts. Many thanks with regard to offering all of us such a beneficial facts. Maintain the great do the job as well as continue offering all of us far more quality facts every now and then. If at all possible, when you obtain ability, do you thoughts modernizing your blog along with additional information
    Wireless Internet Card

    ReplyDelete